I think we're getting off topic here. The discussion was about an untucked shirt and how that should be perceived.
And I think the perception that an untucked shirt is something worth being frowned upon isn't helping garner interest. I know that if I'm active and playing - I tend to watch more pro golf on the boob tube. At the end of the season, when I'm not playing - I tend to tune in a lot less. I don't think I'm alone in this thinking.
If you don't play golf - you're probably not watching golf on tv, except for maybe the majors, and even then it's very dependent on what you have going on in your life at the time.
The game can continue evolving without giving up all of its traditions. But if the caretakers and powers-that-be don't make a concerted effort to make the game more inclusive versus exclusive - the growth of the game is going to struggle. Not suggesting private clubs shouldn't continue existing... I'm a private club member, a part of the shirt-tucked-in crowd. But do I think the stereotype of golf being stuffy and restrictive is hurting interest? You bet. Public courses ultimately comprise the majority of revenue in the industry overall.
Considering how many people were employed in the industry back in the mid-2000's compared to how many people are employed in the industry today - I think it's safe to assume a lot of people have been forced to find a different line of work.
That's not good for the economy, that's not good for business owners who employ locals, and obviously it's not good for those who love working in the industry...