I haven't made many eagles in my golfing career and the last one was on a par 4 from about 120 yards....actually hit a low hook around a tree that ran on the green and in lol. Most of my eagles are on par 4 holes. There are only 2 par 5's on my course and I have almost no shot at getting on them in 2. I did actually hit a couple of short par 4's in 1 (hugely downwind and playing < 300) a while back and 3 jacked both. One I was probably at least 60 ft away, but the other was maybe 30 so that was a dagger to the heart.
I think the worst hole I can remember was at my father in laws club probably 20-25 years ago. It's a 440 something yard par 4 built into a mountain playing steeply downhill. I crushed an old persimmon 3 wood up the left side, it caught the cart path and wound up pin high just off the green. A decent player may have chipped it in, but I made a 6 😞