How did you shoot today at Golf

ode Again, I find this fascinating. Data that I have seen have shown that balls that hit the pin and miss also miss with the pin out, and stay closer to the hole (thus making the next putt easier).

It amazes me that this question somehow hasn't yet been definitively answered. Give me a stimpmeter, a bunch of golf balls, and about a week and I could tell you everything there is to know about the subject. I would roll thousands of balls at just past the hole speed, two feet past the hole speed, five feet past the hole speed; I would roll them over the right third of the hole, the middle of the hole, and the left side of the hole. Uphillers, downhillers, left breakers and right breakers. I would calculate not just how many went in but the also what the leave was for the putts that missed.

I am inclined to think that leaving the pin in would overall be advantageous for virtually everybody. I think the pin saves people a lot more than it harms them.

Again, it astounds me that somebody hasn't already done an exhaustive study.

rsvman2 I am inclined to think that leaving the pin in would overall be advantageous for virtually everybody. I think the pin saves people a lot more than it harms them.
Again, it astounds me that somebody hasn't already done an exhaustive study.

I just read a report somewhere this week that described just such a test. And it concluded that your assumption is correct.....that leaving the pin in provides an advantage to golfers as opposed to removing it. I always feel like the pin is a backstop for putts.....Will see if I can find the article....

We've been leaving the pin in since the rule changed. Been doing it for so long now that it looks weird when the pin is out.

fatshot Ian BF during a broadcast last year indicated it has been studied and proven that pin out was the best method.....not sure what "study" he was referring to.

ode https://www.golfdigest.com/story/the-science-behind-why-the-flagstick-should-be-pulled-999-percent-of-the-time

Sparky I've had the pin reject the ball a lot more times than it has helped me.

I like the pin out. The hole isn't any larger, but it has more room in it.

Bravopilot

TLDR. I'll take his word for it.

Bravopilot thanks.....that is essentially my experience ....glancing blows are more likely then direct hits and the risk is it will get knocked out vs. in. Those that like the pin in for some sort of visual reference should have someone tend vs. leave it in.

Now am I going to get off my dead ass and take the pin out

fatshot

I used to pay close attention to the yearly ball test, but take it with a grain of salt. It is good to see the #'s as long as I've played one of the balls and it's a known commodity to compare up against the others, otherwise it's essentially useless. They are paid and I don't trust what they say, especially their own conclusions of the data.

ode If you'd take time to learn how to putt correctly.....ball dies in hole.....you'd not be worrying about nonsense.
And 'flag in/flag out' is just that, nonsense.

Typhoon in fairness you probably hit your 7 iron farther than they hit their driver.
And grammar experts. Do you hit your driver farther or further?

rsvman2 I always leave the pin in. Simply out of laziness. I only remember two times where I felt it hurt me for the whole year. Definitely helped more then that with a few hot putts dropping after hitting the stick. I don't think it matters one way or the other statistically over the course of the whole season.

DonM Agree, farther is a literal measure and further much more subjective/symbolic. I think of it as when reminding a bud I seriously kicked his ass with my drive that went further than theirs. However, the distance farther might have been inching past.

Bravopilot It's farther whether it goes by his drive by an inch or by 40 yards.

My post is taking this discussion further.