I actually haven't watched Scrooged. I'm so much of a fan of the Sim's version I hardly want to watch any others. I remember going to see the Muppet version in the theater when it came out and enjoying it very much and I've seen a few stage versions that I liked. I have only seen bits and pieces of the George C. Scott, Patrick Stewart, or Jim Carrey versions, and I like some of the other works by those actors. I'm just too fond of the 1951 version. It was the first one I saw as a child in a theater Saturday matinee sometime around 1971, and it has biased me against any other movie version. I do need to make it a point to see Scrooged though since I guess it is not a period piece and should be uniquely different.