rsvman2 Well FWIW I think you have a nice looking swing. I agree with Sneaky that it is tough to completely judge without seeing ballflight in person or on a LM.
I play regularly with a guy that has the ugliest looking swing you've ever seen, but he generally hits the ball quite well. His chipping is also not what you would call ideal or even decent, but he makes it work and he is probably the best putter I have played with. His brother is the polar opposite. Textbook swing and nice tempo and everything looks right, but when he's off the ball is going sideways and he is one of the worst putters I've seen lol.