KCee
We share several similarities or preferences.
My fitting several years ago took me from a face balanced model to a slight arc.
Plumber neck putters don’t fit my eye either. Too much material is distracting and found the original Tour Black Spider (ugly by many standards) slant neck to be appealing with the “T” alignment.
The clean look short slant neck hosel takes my eye to the face, not the busy back of the Spider. Toe hang of 20. Even though I was fitted for 33” I went to 34” to help use the arc, avoid cutting across the ball, and standing taller, taking stress off my back. My lie too is 68.
My thought is to add weight to the Spider, simple fix, extend the shaft or reshaft by adding two inches, adding a longer grip and then the weights.
Thanks!