fatshot they want $12.59 to ship it 100 miles....!!!
Sorry, but... So?
Take Option 2 then - The option where you get into your car and drive an hour and 40 minutes to 2 hours one way.
Pick it up and drive back another couple of hours.
God forbid you wanna' stop at Wendy's for a Frosty.
That's 4 hours in the car.
The cost of gas for a 200 mile round tripper, even if you are getting 30 mpg, that's about 6 gallons at $3.50 or $21.00
Forget about the Frosty... You still pissed away 4 to 5 hours of your day (if your time is worth nothing) plus $21 bucks in gas.
Of course, Option 1 is still available at $12.59 as you said.